05 February 2021
My only option, in Greece, for a 225 50 r15 tire, which is all weather, V rating, and not, just, for the left wheels, as some directional tires are, suitable for a fast 4x4 car.
Nankang xr611 M+S
( Wave tread pattern, Pirelli 1995, P6000)
A comparison based on a 2013 test of 54 summer tires:
tyrereviews.uk 2013 test 54 Summer tires
tyrereviews.uk 2017 test 11 All season tires
And here is a synthesis of the data of the Summer 2013 test to All season tires of the year 2017:
Recommended! (My humble opinion).
“…and a primary object of the present invention is to provide a pneumatic tire which is improved in the steering stability on dry roads and running performance on snowy/icy roads by improving the configurations of sipes”.
German magazine "Auto Bild" has published the "Summer Tire Super Test 2015". The tested tire size was 185/60 R15, test vehicle a VW Polo.
This test is a special test
with 53 participating products. The evaluation consists of 2 parts:
Part 1: dry and wet braking test, selection of the 18 best products, called
"Finalists":
N° |
Brand |
Model |
Braking distance, m |
Total, m |
|
wet |
dry |
||||
1 |
Pirelli |
Cinturato P1 Verde |
47,5 |
37,0 |
84,5 |
2 |
Continental |
PremiumContact 5 |
48,1 |
36,6 |
84,7 |
3 |
Dunlop |
Sport BluResponse |
49,5 |
35,9 |
85,4 |
4 |
Bridgestone |
Turanza T001 |
49,8 |
36,4 |
86,2 |
5 |
Hankook |
Kinergy Eco K425 |
50,2 |
36,3 |
86,5 |
6 |
Nexen |
N'Blue HD Plus |
51,2 |
35,7 |
86,9 |
7 |
Goodyear |
EfficientGrip Performance |
51,8 |
36,1 |
87,9 |
8 |
Fulda |
EcoControl HP |
52,6 |
36,1 |
88,7 |
9 |
Sava |
Intensa HP |
51,4 |
37,5 |
88,9 |
10 |
Vredestein |
Sportrac 5 |
53,2 |
36,0 |
89,2 |
11 |
Falken |
Ziex ZE914 Ecorun |
53,3 |
36,0 |
89,3 |
12 |
Michelin |
Energy Saver+ |
53,4 |
36,9 |
90,3 |
13 |
Zeetex |
ZT1000 |
52,8 |
37,7 |
90,5 |
14 |
Kumho |
Ecowing ES01 KH27 |
54,2 |
36,7 |
90,9 |
15 |
Roadstone |
CP 661 |
52,7 |
39,3 |
92,0 |
16 |
Uniroyal |
RainExpert |
53,5 |
39,2 |
92,7 |
17 |
Apollo |
Alnac 4G |
56,2 |
37,6 |
93,8 |
18 |
Yokohama |
BluEarth AE-01 |
56,8 |
37,9 |
94,7 |
19 |
Semperit |
Comfort Life 2 |
55,4 |
39,7 |
95,1 |
20 |
Barum |
Brillantis 2 |
55,2 |
40,0 |
95,2 |
21 |
Dayton |
D210 |
58,6 |
36,6 |
95,2 |
22 |
Torque |
TQ021 |
56,9 |
38,7 |
95,6 |
23 |
Nankang |
XR611 Toursport |
60,3 |
35,4 |
95,7 |
24 |
Hi Fly |
HF201 |
58,2 |
38,2 |
96,4 |
25 |
Firestone |
TZ300 |
57,6 |
39,5 |
97,1 |
26 |
Riken |
Maystorm 2b² |
60,3 |
37,2 |
97,5 |
27 |
Nokian |
Line |
60,0 |
37,8 |
97,8 |
28 |
Taurus |
Touring 301 |
60,2 |
37,8 |
98,0 |
29 |
Petlas |
Imperium PT515 |
58,6 |
39,5 |
98,1 |
30 |
GT Radial |
Champiro 228 |
60,1 |
38,2 |
98,3 |
31 |
Viking |
City Tech II |
60,6 |
37,8 |
98,4 |
32 |
Evergreen |
EH23 |
61,2 |
37,6 |
98,8 |
33 |
Maxxis |
Victra 510 |
61,5 |
37,7 |
99,2 |
34 |
Starmaxx |
Novaro ST532 |
61,7 |
37,7 |
99,4 |
35 |
Matador |
MP16 |
59,2 |
40,5 |
99,7 |
36 |
Zeta |
ZTR20 |
61,8 |
37,9 |
99,7 |
37 |
Marshal |
Matrac MH11 |
61,5 |
38,6 |
100,1 |
38 |
Kleber |
Dynaxer HP3 |
62,4 |
38,1 |
100,5 |
39 |
Tracmax |
F-101 |
63,1 |
37,7 |
100,8 |
40 |
Gilsaved |
Urban*Speed |
62,2 |
39,1 |
101,3 |
41 |
Trazano |
H550-A |
64,5 |
37,7 |
102,2 |
42 |
General |
Altimax Comfort |
63,0 |
40,0 |
103,0 |
43 |
Cooper |
CS2 |
63,8 |
39,4 |
103,2 |
44 |
King Meiler |
Sport 1 |
66,0 |
37,7 |
103,7 |
45 |
Avon |
ZT5 |
64,1 |
39,8 |
103,9 |
46 |
Sailun |
Atrezzo SH402 |
71,2 |
38,6 |
109,8 |
47 |
Insa Turbo |
Ecosaver-E |
69,7 |
41,3 |
111,0 |
48 |
Tristar |
F109 Ecopower 2 |
72,3 |
39,1 |
111,4 |
49 |
Autogrip |
F101 |
71,9 |
39,7 |
111,6 |
50 |
Toyo |
Nanoenergy 2 |
73,6 |
38,1 |
111,7 |
51 |
Silverstone |
Synenergie M5 |
73,2 |
39,5 |
112,7 |
52 |
Rotalla |
F109 |
74,1 |
39,3 |
113,4 |
53 |
Maxtrek |
SU-830 |
85,6 |
39,1 |
124,7 |
Here seems that the Nankang xr611 takes the # 23 position.
But, as in many other matters, the azimuth of the visual angle, may blur the clear, at a first glance, picture.
Firstly, the #23 Nankang xr611 m+s tire, beats the #1 SUMMER tire Pirelli P1 Cinturato Verde FOR THE DRY BRAKING by 1.6 m! Mission impossible for an all weather m+s tire.
Secondly, if we compare the results to all weather tires, another reality is revealed. And, yes, the data are comparable, since the same tires have a similar behavior, independently of the size or the vehicle it is used, within some error limits.
No comments!
14 February 2021
Anyone to recommend the xr611?
Well, except those who trust it in sizes above 205, where the tread pattern is different in comparison to smaller sizes, in terms of analogies, seems to be difficult.
But just a moment! There is a very big and serious one! In fact, he is so enthusiastic about it, that he goes one step ahead and even produces the tire!
Tires are on!
A sneak peak on a wet surface road is my first 10 km course.
What an irony! Sharp turns on a narrow country side road, when wet! Exactly on the wild side, according to the reviewers, I felt in danger!
But I went from, (Bridgestone Adrenalin r002, 8.5 kgr), 205 55 r15 to, (Nankang xr611, 9.5 kgr), 225 50 r15, wider tires, with the same, 6J r15, oem Sebring, wheels. Is it a matter of the 4wd, 4wt, of the car? Or of the wider tires?
At 40 psi, (vs 38 psi for the Bridgestone), all around, Nankang works as a magic carpet, absorbing much better the road noise, and this is easily understood as a matter of a softer carcass.
The handling on the wet tarmac, on the other hand, is unexpected, as well as, the reaction through the standing waters.
But a 10 km.road is a very short distance...
17 February 2021
Fate brought it and my first impressions about my Nankangs are for the rare cases, in my region, of the wet tarmac, as well as, of snowy roads, not having the opportunity to drive under the normal circumstances, for me, yet.
Climbing on a snowy hill seems to be extremely easy for my Syncro g60 with the xr611 Nankangs. Much easier than with my Bridgestone Adrenalin, although the xr611 are wider. For a level road, they behave perfectly on the, fresh, snow. Driving on the snow remains, almost, unnoticed, (for low speed of course)!
18 February 2021
M+S or not?
23 February 2021